Barzini’s is Back: Gets ‘A’ Grade in Health Inspection

barzini's accusations

Google Maps

The “Temporarily Closed for Maintenance” signs are gone. In their place, an ‘A’ grade from the New York State Department of Agriculture and Markets is now posted at Barzini’s, the 24-hour grocer at 2451 Broadway by the corner of 91st Street. The store has officially reopened after passing its health inspection on Monday, February 10.

Advertisement




The saga isn’t officially over—Barzini’s must pass a follow-up inspection or face another shutdown if critical violations are found. Under an agreement reached last week between the store’s lawyers and the State Department of Agriculture and Markets, the grocer—an Upper West Side staple for more than 40 years—was given a path to reopen and regain its 20-C food license. The store must also pay a $14,400 fine and have its employees complete a food safety course.

Barzini’s was ordered to shut down in January after inspectors found “severe insanitary conditions” on the premises, including rodent gnaw marks on products and packaging, grain beetles in assorted pasta in the retail area, and a live brood of rats in the kitchen walk-in cooler. The grocer reopened and closed multiple times while under orders to remain shut and pass re-inspection.

When we spoke to Barzini’s manager in late January about the drama surrounding the store, he said, “We’ve had exterminators here every day,” emphasizing that the space had been cleaned up. “We closed all the holes,” he added.

Advertisement



“This is the right outcome. We want to make sure the owner meets his obligations in order to reopen and stay open safely,” said City Council Member Gale Brewer in a text message to ILTUWS.

ILTUWS received an outpouring of comments about Barzini’s amidst the health code scandal. Some comments were about credit cards being overcharged or double-charged, a matter we covered in 2022, along with accusations of selling expired cheese. We’ll see if these issues resurface, along with concerns about cleanliness, in the new era of Barzini’s.

Have a news tip? Send it to us here!


.





Latest Comments

  1. Nate February 12, 2025
  2. Mark February 13, 2025
  3. George February 13, 2025
  4. Quenchy February 13, 2025
    • Roger Maltby February 13, 2025
  5. Albert February 13, 2025
  6. Cyrus February 13, 2025
  7. Lifelong Upper Westsider February 13, 2025

Leave a Reply to Lifelong Upper Westsider Cancel reply

Advertisement