Made in New York Pizza Opens Second UWS Location

  Last modified on July 21st, 2023
made in new york pizza amsterdam ave

Made in New York Pizza’s new location can be found at 271 Amsterdam Avenue, between 72nd and 73rd Streets

When Made in New York Pizza landed on the Upper West Side it became a quick favorite for many. Dare we say it’s pizza-riffic?


Its spicy pepperoni pizza is a thing of beauty. Each pie is draped with an entire pound of the highest quality pepperoni, the kind that curls into those crispy-edged cups.

Made in New York Pizza UWS

Now we have some good news and some bad news.

The good news is that Made in New York Pizza has officially doubled down in the ‘hood as its second UWS location opened this week at 271 Amsterdam Ave, between 72nd and 73rd streets. The now mini-chain has a third spot in the West Village.

Now the bad news:  The pizza isn’t calorie-free.

In addition to the spicy pepperoni, other specialty pizzas include sausage and jalapeño, a grandma pie, an upside down pie and a white pie that will dazzle the taste buds of vegetarians in the same way the spicy pepperoni delights carnivores. There are also gluten-free options and for the carbo-loaders, there are pretty tasty garlic knots.

Here is a look at the menu from the original UWS location at 412 Amsterdam Ave (corner of 80th Street).

The new location, while smaller than the flagship, has indoor and outdoor seating and offers pickup and delivery (reach them at 646.449.8556).

Sharing is caring!

Latest Comments

  1. Pizza Peter August 26, 2022
    • Jay August 28, 2022
  2. steve August 27, 2022
    • Pete August 27, 2022
      • Jay August 27, 2022
        • Jay August 27, 2022
  3. Jay August 27, 2022

Leave a Reply