Six of the Oldest Bars on the Upper West Side

  Last modified on January 30th, 2020

The Upper West Side has a rich history, and its watering holes are no exception.  Here are six that have stood the test of time.

Dublin House – 1920s

225 West 79th Street, between Broadway and Amsterdam

Dublin House first opened during the Prohibition era of the 1920s, officially opening as a legal pub in 1933. It’s easily recognized by its neon harp sign (even by those who’ve never walked in). This true Irish bar is perfect for those looking to escape to simpler times. During the winter they offer classic warm concoctions like Irish coffee, mulled cider and hot toddies. The beer list is pretty simple. Which might just add to those “simpler times” you’re looking to experience.

Dublin House


Amsterdam Ale House (Originally Sweeney’s) – 1930s

340 Amsterdam Avenue (corner of 76th Street)

Established as Sweeney’s in the 1930’s, then Westside Brewing Company from the 1950s, and more recently renamed Amsterdam Ale House. When this bar was first established in the thirties, the Upper West Side had cobblestone streets, and the bar was adorned with stained glass windows from Tiffany’s.  The cobblestones are gone, but the stained glass windows still remain today.

Today, Amsterdam Ale House is an excellent option for those seeking an extensive beer list.

Amsterdam Ale House NYC


Emerald Inn – 1943

250 West 72nd Street (between West End and Broadway)

The Emerald Inn has been owned by the same family since its founding in 1943.  It was located between 69th and 70th Street until 2013, when the landlord nearly doubled their rent, at which time they moved to a new location on 72nd Street. A low-key, no-frills watering hole, it was the filming location of the Christmas Eve scene of the 1960 film The Apartment, and saw celebrities such as James Gandolfini and Regis Philbin, and star classical singer Bryn Terfel.

Stop by Emerald Inn for some burgers and wings!

Emerald Inn Columbus Avenue

Emerald Inn’s old Columbus Avenue location. c/o Flickr user Jazz Guy


Frank Mac’s (originally McAleer’s): 1953

425 Amsterdam Ave (between 80th and 81st Streets)

Operating since 1953, Frank Mac’s Pub was known as McAleer’s until a name change in late 2018.  A popular location for British and Celtic foods like Shepherd’s Pie, Frank Mac’s also supports a full offering of bar food and a sidewalk patio.

Frank Macs Interior


Malachy’s Donegal Inn (originally Blarney Castle) – 1950s?

103 West 72nd Street (between Broadway and Columbus Ave)

We called the bar twice and spoke to two different people, neither of whom knew the date Malachy’s was established.  But according to Sideways NYC, the no-frills dive bar was established in 1989.

A few of our readers informed us that the bar existed well before it became Malachy’s in 1989. But unfortunately, at this point, we are unsure of the exact date. Feel free to contact us if you know anything!

Head to this Irish standby for reasonably priced drinks and a standard but quality bar menu. Malachy’s takes up a small sidewalk footprint on the northwest corner of 72nd and Columbus.

Malachy's UWS


Dive Bar – 1989

732 Amsterdam (96th)

Dive Bar’s original location on Amsterdam and 96th Street was founded in 1989. Today, the Upper West Side has four Dive Bars! The original spot – which earned a place in our list of best UWS bars – comes with 43 beer taps and tons of bottles, a popular poutine, delicious wings and weekly trivia nights.

Dive Bar 96th Street

 Get the UWS newsletter: 

Sharing is caring!