A Protest at Gracie Mansion

  Last modified on August 26th, 2022

On Sunday, September 13, Upper West Siders and others marched from The Lucerne Hotel to Gracie Mansion to protest Mayor de Blasio for his recent decision to relocate Lucerne Hotel residents to the Harmonia shelter on 31st Street. This has so far resulted in the displacement on 17 families, but according the The Legal Aid Society, the displacement has been put on a pause. The Legal Aid Society states that 80% of the Harmonia’s residents are disabled.

UPDATE: A Temporary Pause on Lucerne Hotel Relocations

In response to the city’s decision to relocate these groups, The Legal Aid Society has made it clear that they are preparing a lawsuit.


homeless residents lucerne protest gracie mansion

The Sunday protest lasted several hours and participants stated they would not leave until their demands were met, with some also calling for Mayor de Blasio’s resignation.

After Sunday’s rally, the following press release was published by UWS Open Hearts:

After the rally at 86th and East End, the group of shelter residents, supportive community members, activists, and elected officials marched directly to the entrance of Gracie Mansion to deliver their message to the Mayor. Councilmember Helen Rosenthal together with Harmonia and Lucerne residents, UWS Open Hearts Initiative, and Councilmember Ben Kallos demanded that Mayor de Blasio’s office hold meetings with residents and staff of Project Renewal at the Lucerne and residents and staff of The Harmonia before Legal Aid’s negotiations with DHS over transfers are resolved.

After waiting at Gracie Mansion for over THREE hours, Councilmember Rosenthal received commitment that Marco A. Carrión, commissioner of Community Affairs, would personally meet with residents and staff at both shelters before any more transfers take place, so the Mayor can hear directly from residents how traumatic, disruptive, and counter-productive these transfers will be.
After receiving this commitment, Harmonia shelter resident Mike Bonano personally delivered our “notice of transfer” to de Blasio’s staff. “We are asking for the Mayor to meet with the shelter homeless people who he is displacing, prior to making his final decision,” said City Councilmember Helen Rosenthal.
The ripple effect of his decision, prior to meeting with those who don’t know where they are sleeping tonight, is unconscionable. “What I want is safety and a roof over my head, and not to be pushed around from shelter to shelter. This is our third time being displaced, we’re tired of being treated like garbage,” said Mike Bonani, resident at Harmonia Shelter. “To the Mayor, my hope is that you read into what is being said today and begin to really think about the humanity of those you serve whether rich or poor,” said Da Homeless Hero, a resident at the Lucerne.

Attorney Randy Mastro, who represents the West Side Community Organization, put out the following statement:

“We understand and expect that the City will honor its commitment to move folks out of the Lucerne and into state-accredited shelters with proper services on-site by the end of this month. As the Mayor has explained, SRO hotels should only be temporary housing, and what’s happening on the Upper West Side is ‘not acceptable,’ so this move will be a win-win for this neighborhood and this vulnerable population.”

Click here for earlier coverage

Sharing is caring!

Latest Comments

  1. Exhausted on the UWS September 14, 2020
  2. UWS person September 14, 2020
    • Harriet September 15, 2020
  3. dc September 14, 2020
    • UWS person September 14, 2020
  4. S September 14, 2020
    • uws September 15, 2020
  5. The Regressive Left September 15, 2020
    • Derek September 15, 2020
  6. Ian Alterman September 15, 2020
    • Small Business Owner September 15, 2020
      • Ian Alterman September 15, 2020
        • Small Business Owner September 15, 2020
          • Ian Alterman September 15, 2020
            • Small Business Owner September 15, 2020
              • Ian Alterman September 15, 2020
      • Harriet September 15, 2020
  7. King September 15, 2020
    • Ian Alterman September 15, 2020
  8. Derek September 15, 2020

Leave a Reply